McClave Builders Blog

Renovating an Older Home in Phoenixville or Pottstown

November 18, 2026

Much of the housing in Phoenixville, Pottstown, Spring City, and Royersford was built long before modern building codes. Twins and rowhomes from the steel and industrial era, stone farmhouses, and early twentieth-century foursquares give these towns their character. They also make renovations less predictable. The finishes you see are rarely the whole story, and the surprises behind the walls are what drive budgets and schedules off course.

You can’t eliminate every unknown in an older house, but you can plan for the common ones. Here is what we tell homeowners to expect before they open up walls in a house that is 80 to 150 years old.

Plaster and Lath Change the Math

Most pre-war homes have three-coat plaster over wood lath instead of drywall. It is dense, quiet, and durable, but it changes how work gets done.

  • Demolition is slower, heavier, and dustier than drywall removal, and it fills dumpsters fast
  • Running new wiring or plumbing through plaster walls takes more cutting and patching
  • Blending new drywall into old plaster takes skill, because the wall thicknesses rarely match
  • Sound plaster in rooms you aren’t renovating can often be repaired instead of removed

Decide early which rooms will be fully opened and which will be patched. That single decision affects demolition, insulation, electrical, and finish costs across the whole project.

Wiring and Plumbing From Another Era

Older homes often carry several generations of systems at once. It is common to find original knob-and-tube wiring still live in some circuits, ungrounded cloth-insulated cable in others, and newer wiring spliced in by previous owners. Plumbing tells a similar story: galvanized steel supply lines that have narrowed with rust, cast iron drains, and occasional lead service pipes.

When walls are open, that is the cheapest time to replace these systems. Before demolition, ask your contractor and electrician to walk the house and identify:

  • Whether the electrical service size can handle new appliances, heat pumps, or a car charger
  • Which circuits are original and which have been updated
  • What the main water line and drain stack are made of
  • Whether the renovation will trigger requirements to update systems beyond the work area

That last point matters. Depending on the scope, your township’s code official may require upgrades such as smoke and carbon monoxide detection or GFCI protection in areas you didn’t plan to touch. Confirm with your township before you finalize the budget.

Framing That Has Settled and Shifted

A century of settling leaves its mark. Floors slope, door frames go out of square, and ceilings dip. Some of that is cosmetic. Some of it points to undersized joists, notched or cut framing from past plumbing jobs, or a beam that has been carrying more than it should for decades.

Many older homes are also balloon framed, with wall studs running continuously from the foundation to the roof. Those open wall cavities let air, and fire, travel between floors. Renovations are a good time to add fire blocking and air sealing.

Plan on these practical steps:

  • Have a structural engineer look at any wall removal, sagging floor, or new load such as a stone countertop or tiled shower
  • Agree up front how level and plumb new work needs to be, and how it will transition to old floors that aren’t
  • Expect custom trim and carpentry where off-the-shelf doors and casings won’t fit out-of-square openings

Stone Foundations and Damp Basements

Fieldstone and rubble foundations are common in the older parts of Chester and Montgomery Counties. They have stood a long time, but they were never meant to be dry. Mortar joints erode, water finds its way through, and basements stay humid much of the year.

If your renovation includes the basement, or puts new mechanical equipment down there, deal with water first. Repointing mortar, correcting grading and downspouts, and managing humidity usually come before any finish work. Sealing a stone wall behind new framing without a moisture plan tends to trap water where you can’t see it.

Lead Paint and Other Hazardous Materials

Assume lead paint is present in any home built before 1978. Federal rules require lead-safe work practices when renovation disturbs painted surfaces in these homes, including containment, cleanup, and verification. That affects how demolition is set up and how long it takes, especially if children live in the house.

Older homes can also contain asbestos in pipe insulation, old floor tiles and mastic, and some plaster or siding products. If materials are suspect, have them tested by a qualified lab before demolition starts. Testing is inexpensive compared to stopping work mid-project.

Historic Districts and Local Review

Some boroughs in our area have local historic districts with extra review for exterior changes. Phoenixville, for example, has a Downtown Historic District where a Historical Architectural Review Board reviews visible exterior alterations, and a certificate of appropriateness is needed before certain building permits are issued. A larger area of the borough is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which generally carries different rules for private homeowners.

If your project changes windows, siding, porches, or rooflines, check with your borough or township early. Review boards meet on set schedules, so build that time into your plan rather than discovering it after you have materials on order.

How to Budget for the Unknowns

Costs vary widely with the age of the house, the scope, and the finishes, so there is no reliable rule of thumb for an older-home premium. What you can control is how you handle what you find:

  1. Invest in investigation during preconstruction. Small exploratory openings, an engineer’s visit, and materials testing turn unknowns into line items.
  2. Carry a contingency set aside specifically for conditions behind walls, separate from upgrades you might choose later.
  3. Agree on how discoveries will be handled: who documents them, how they are priced, and how quickly decisions need to be made.
  4. Sequence the work so systems and structure are fixed before finishes go in, even if it delays the visible progress.

A transparent pricing structure helps here. When you can see actual costs as conditions are uncovered, it is easier to make clear decisions instead of arguing over allowances.

Start With the Right Plan

Older homes reward careful planning. The houses that turn out best are the ones where the owner and builder agreed early on how far to open things up, what to fix while walls are open, and how surprises would be handled.

McClave Builders works on older and historic homes across Chester and Montgomery Counties, including Phoenixville and Pottstown. Our structured preconstruction process, in-house carpentry, and cost-plus pricing are built for exactly this kind of work. Learn more about our remodeling and renovation services, then contact us or call (610) 300-5585 to talk through your project.