McClave Builders Blog

How Change Orders Work During a Home Renovation

November 11, 2026

Almost every renovation has at least one change order. You open a wall and find rotted framing. You see the cabinets go in and decide the island should be a foot longer. The township inspector asks for something the plans did not show. None of that means the project is going wrong. It means a real house is being built from a set of drawings, and the two never line up perfectly.

What causes trouble is not the change itself but how it gets handled. A change agreed to in a quick hallway conversation, with no price and no paperwork, is how budgets drift and relationships sour. Here is how change orders should work, what a good one looks like, and how to keep them under control on your project.

What a Change Order Is

A change order is a written amendment to your construction contract. It records a change in scope, cost, schedule, or all three, and both you and the contractor sign it before the changed work starts. Once signed, it becomes part of the contract just like the original scope.

Changes generally come from three places:

  • Owner-requested changes. You add a window, upgrade the tile, move a doorway, or decide to finish the attic while the crew is already there.
  • Hidden or unforeseen conditions. Things nobody could see before demolition: damaged sills, undersized joists, old knob-and-tube wiring, or water damage behind a shower wall. These are common in the older homes found throughout Chester and Montgomery Counties.
  • Required changes. An inspector, engineer, or utility requires something different from what was planned. Requirements vary by township, so these are hard to predict exactly until plans are reviewed.

What a Good Change Order Includes

A change order does not need to be long, but it should answer every question you would otherwise have to ask later. Look for these items:

  • A clear description of the change. Specific enough that someone who was not in the conversation would understand it. “Extend kitchen island 12 inches toward the dining room, add one base cabinet, revise countertop template” is useful. “Island changes” is not.
  • The cost impact. Labor, materials, and any markup or fee, shown the same way the original contract shows pricing. A change can also be a credit, such as when you drop an item from scope.
  • The schedule impact. How many days the change adds, if any. A small material swap may add nothing. A new window opening may mean an extra inspection or a longer lead time on the unit.
  • Effects on other work. Moving a sink can touch plumbing, electrical, cabinets, and countertops. A good change order notes what else is affected.
  • A running total. The revised contract amount after this change, so you always know where the project stands.
  • Signatures and a date from both parties before the work begins.

How Pricing Works Under Different Contracts

The way a change is priced depends on the type of contract you signed. On a fixed-price contract, every change has to be priced and negotiated as its own mini-contract, and contractors often build a cushion into each one because they carry the risk. On a cost-plus contract, the change is billed like the rest of the job: actual costs plus the agreed fee, with the receipts and labor records available to you.

Neither approach removes the need for paperwork. Even under cost-plus, you should see a written estimate of what the change will likely cost before you approve it, so you are making the decision with real numbers in front of you. If you want a deeper comparison of the two models, we covered it in Cost-Plus vs. Fixed-Price Contracts for Home Renovations.

Timing Matters More Than Most People Expect

The same change can cost very different amounts depending on when you make it. Moving an outlet on paper during design costs almost nothing. Moving it after rough electrical costs an electrician’s visit. Moving it after drywall, paint, and trim means cutting, patching, and refinishing a finished wall.

A useful rule: the further a phase has progressed, the more expensive it is to change anything that phase touched. Before each major phase, walk the space with your contractor and confirm the layout you want:

  1. Before framing: wall locations, door and window openings, ceiling heights.
  2. Before rough mechanicals: outlet, switch, and light locations; plumbing fixture positions; vent and duct routes.
  3. Before insulation and drywall: blocking for grab bars, TVs, shelving, and heavy fixtures; low-voltage and speaker wiring.
  4. Before finishes: tile layout, trim profiles, paint colors, hardware.

How to Keep Change Orders Under Control

You cannot eliminate change orders, but you can keep most of them small and predictable.

  • Define scope thoroughly up front. The more decisions made during preconstruction, the fewer surprises later. Vague allowances and “TBD” items are where most owner changes come from.
  • Finish selections before work starts. Tile, fixtures, appliances, and cabinets chosen in advance let the contractor plan rough-ins correctly the first time.
  • Carry a contingency. Set aside a portion of your budget for unknowns, and plan on a larger cushion for older homes where hidden conditions are more likely. Costs vary widely with scope and the age of the house, so talk through a sensible number with your builder.
  • Route every change through one person. Talk to the project manager, not the tile setter. Trade crews want to help, but a casual “sure, we can do that” on site is how undocumented changes happen.
  • Never approve verbally. If it is not written and signed, it is not approved. This protects you and the contractor equally.
  • Batch small changes. If you have three minor tweaks, raise them together so they can be priced and scheduled at once instead of interrupting the crew three times.

Red Flags to Watch For

Be cautious if a contractor refuses to put changes in writing, bills for changes you never signed, or produces a stack of change orders at the end of the job that you are seeing for the first time. Another warning sign is a very low initial bid followed by frequent “required” changes for items that should have been obvious during the walkthrough. A thorough proposal and a careful site visit should catch most foreseeable work before the contract is signed.

Talk Through Your Project With McClave Builders

At McClave Builders, we use a structured preconstruction process and transparent cost-plus pricing so changes are documented, priced openly, and approved before work moves forward. Whether you are planning a kitchen in Phoenixville or a whole-home renovation elsewhere in Chester or Montgomery County, we will walk you through how changes are handled before the first wall comes down. You can see examples of our work in our portfolio.

To start a conversation, contact us online or call (610) 300-5585.